School recorders under $15 (Yamaha YRS-23 vs YRS-24B)
If your school asks for a Baroque or English soprano recorder, look for the Yamaha YRS-24B. If the list says German fingering, the Yamaha YRS-23 matches. With a budget under $15, check the price with shipping and tax before ordering.
Check a Yamaha or Aulos model against your school supply list, or make a list to share with families.
Which recorder should I buy for third-grade music class?
Use the teacher's supply list. If it gives a model number, take it to the shop. If it only says “soprano” or “descant,” you have the right size, but you still need to know which fingering the class uses. Ask the teacher, “Do you use Baroque or German fingering for F?”
Yamaha YRS-23 or YRS-24B?
Both are plastic soprano recorders in C. A child can play B, A and G the same way on either, so the first tune can sound fine even with the other model. The difference shows up on low F. On the Baroque YRS-24B, the right ring finger and little finger cover holes near the foot. On the German YRS-23, those holes stay open for F.
See the low F fingering on a soprano recorder. For a secondhand instrument, check the model number against Yamaha’s guide to the two systems. If the model matches and the joints fit snugly, ask the teacher whether your child can bring it to class. If the delivered price is over $15, ask whether the school has a loaner.
When buying nothing makes sense
If you have a recorder from school or can borrow one, identify it before replacing it. A German soprano can use Piper's German setting. B, A and G have the same fingerings in both systems, so you can try a first phrase on a playable instrument before committing to a purchase. Check an instrument's condition and follow its maker's cleaning advice, especially when borrowing.
For a child, check that the holes can be covered comfortably. A larger instrument is not an automatic next step. Ask the teacher if a reach problem prevents a full seal.
A model to compare
The Yamaha YRS-24B is a plastic C soprano with Baroque fingering and a straight windway. Yamaha lists the size, fingering and windway in its soprano recorder specifications.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Yamaha YRS-24B: check current price on Amazon.com (US).
Check tax, shipping, the seller and the exact model. Read the return policy for recorders before opening one; hygiene exclusions may apply. A local shop or another retailer may also fit your budget. You do not need to buy through this link to use Piper's lessons.
Choose a recorder or try the quiz · Try your first lesson
Updated 20 November 2026.